KU2
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com

Paypal Dispute

who's talking here?

TexasOma 2
FabFive 6
whatchamacallit 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

FabFive --- 13 years ago -

Hey, I was wondering if anyone more experience with paypal could help me?

Nov 23rd I purchased a Nintendo DS on Ebay coming from China. They don't make them here in the US anymore and it's the same kind my girls have so I was trying to get them all the same. The item never arrived within the 24 business day time frame. They had a tracking number showing it was stuck in Customs but I had no way of knowing if that was in fact my item or not. Dec 19 I told them that I was going to have to file a claim with Paypal so I didn't miss out on my window of time to file. They offered to refund my money and I told them I didn't want to return the DS if I ever got it, and who knows if I ever would. The point was that I now had to go purchase a new DS from game stop and it wasn't the same kind and I didn't want it. I figured if I ever got the one from China I could sell the Game Stop one and call it even.

They cancelled the transaction and "refunded" my money by starting a new paypal transaction showing it was a purchase. BEing the idiot I am, I just saw my money in my account and called it even.

Fast forward to Jan 13th, the item finally arrives. Within minutes of it arriving they are emailing me telling me they want half their money now. I said absolutely not. Then they tell me they only want $50. They said I could mail the item back. I said no, that's not what they agreed to when refunding the money.

I wake up today to find they have filed a dispute with paypal for the $80 claiming they never received the item they bought from me. I am mad as a hornet!

So I called PAypal and even though it's outside of the 45 day dispute window for my item they are allowing it to open. They can check all your Ebay messages and saw all the messages displayed and saw what I was saying is true. She said I should just send back the DS to them. I can't even get to it, it's packed in boxes somewhere. No telling where. So the way she made it sound was that at the end of the day I was probably going to win my claim for the original money and he was going to win his claim of no item received and then we would both be even. ARE YOU KIDDING ME? How can someone so blatantly cheat lie and steal and it's considered acceptable.

He deliberately cancelled the original transaction and created a new one so he could extort the money out of me, and he deliberately waited until the 45 day window of opportunity had passed on MY transaction so he could make his claim.

That will be the last business I do with China and I am probably going to close my paypal account. Next time I'm not buying anywhere I can't use a credit card. At least they do protect the consumer.

At this point I am waiting for an email that tells me if I win my money back or not. Why on EARTH did I give them that kind of control by buying on Ebay in the first place? 

TexasOma (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

I pretty much stopped using Ebay about 2 years ago.

I'm thinking that part of your problem may have been ordering something that came from out of country. They have no reason to be honest and they have learned to scam Americans (probably other capitalistic countries also) and get by with it.

At least PayPal is making it right --- it's sad that the seller is getting money back too. Make sure you give the seller a scathing review - may prevent someone from ever purchasing from them. I think Ebay limits the number of words/characters you can use, so pick out the most choice words for your complaint - make it hurt to the bone.

Have you checked out Amazon for buying things? Amazon seems to have a better reputation for their sellers. 

FabFive --- 13 years ago -

I can't give the seller any review because they cancelled the original transaction.

But, I have thought about repurchasing something from them just to write an awful review to warn others. They had a 100% feedback. Now I know why.

I've bought from Amazon and never had problems. Good Bye Ebay. The sad part is it's hurting the small sellers who are in it to feed their families. The bullies are giving the whole thing a bad name.

My friend on FB told me this exact same thing happened to her on a dress from China. She said they are teaching them how to scam us. Awesome. 

TexasOma (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

It use to be Nigeria was the most scamming country - I guess China is keeping up with them too. They are overtaking us in manufacturing, now gonna catch up with Nigeria in ripoffs. 

FabFive --- 13 years ago -

So I called again tonight to talk to Paypal because it makes me really mad that they can even do this to someone. They picked the wrong person to pick on. The way I worded my emails to them, I covered my butt, even though they cheated. Basically in 11 days the money should be back in my account. The guy I talked to tonight said it was a slam-dunk case but that they did have to go through the proper process. I am still so darn mad and i wonder how many other people have been scammed by this person.

Moral of the story: You only have 45 days to file a claim with paypal. When in doubt, file. Otherwise you lose all recourse. 

whatchamacallit --- 13 years ago -

You can now rate buyers so since the seller changed your purchase into a sale can you rate them? Maybe go to the item in your list and pull the drop down to rate the buyer? Not sure if it would be there but you can now rate buyers without them EVER knowing you do! 

FabFive --- 13 years ago -

Well but they only did that on Paypal, not Ebay.

I am telling you, they orchestrated this perfectly to leave me with no options.

I am blessed that even though it was past the 45 day window someone at paypal had a brain and could see the system was being manipulated and opened a claim for me, even though she shouldn't have. If she hadn't, I would have just had to suck it up. 

FabFive --- 13 years ago -

I just keep going back to how this was so cold and calculated. Someone on my FB told me this same thing happened to her. She said "they don't teach ethics over there". I think she hit the nail on the head. 

whatchamacallit --- 13 years ago -

So, if they don't teach ethics over there why do we (USA) borrow money from them?!?!?! That really bothers me! 

FabFive --- 13 years ago -

Well I finally got it resolved. The trick is to call in and talk to a manager. The manager's are actually able to do something for you. The people you call in to are very nice but they are paid robots from overseas. They are not allowed any authority or to use their brain to figure it out. She closed the case against me and also closed the case I opened. So, it all worked out in the end. I hope to report back that this actually worked, tomorrow. And not that they changed it on me. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

KU2